Key Drivers for Escalating Price Trend in Manhattan

REtop

My goal in this is to give you timely and accurate information on the current
luxury market. If you have any questions or would like for me to cover any
particular topic, I would love to hear your feedback.

Key Drivers for Escalating Price Trend in Manhattan 

As discussed in my previous newsletter, supply and demand remain key issues in the escalating pricing trend across New York City. Inventory is at historic lows, while demand continues to set unprecedented pricing records.

So who is driving up NYC prices?

 

Foreign Buyers

At a recent sales meeting among the company’s top producers, we estimated about half of condo purchases in the city are foreign buyers. And while Co-operatives have been historically overlooked by foreign buyers because of the complexity of buying and owning in a Co-op, they now see Co-ops as the new value play. I had an exceptional sale where a European buyer and local New Yorker went into competitive bidding over a Co-op, pushing the price of the property up 20% above the asking price, which brought it to 30% above the comparable sales (we already had it priced 10% above comps). The European prevailed and was clearly bidding to win. When asked why he had bid so aggressively, he replied that he was in the process of moving assets from Europe to the US because he sees the US, and particularly NYC real estate, as a safe investment compared to a more volatile Europe. It is not uncommon to hear this type of assessment among foreign buyers. Even with our newly escalated prices, the price per square foot is still lower than many other major cities of the world, so they are evaluating NYC real estate from a world market perspective. 

Local Prosperity

According to multiple sources, last year was a lucrative financial year leading to more stock redemptions at the major investment banks in January than any equivalent month since 2007.* Because share prices are so high people are cashing out. Now that the market is back up, it’s likely that the redemptions will continue. We should expect a lot of Wall Streeter’s to be amongst our leading buyers once again, along with the hedge funders. In fact, bonuses increased by 15.1%, while the bonus pool is up 44% in the past 2 years.* Where Wall Streeter’s once lacked liquid compensation and liquid net worth, the redemptions now make them a lot more attractive to Co-op boards. I believe a large portion of these buyers are aiming at the Co-op market because it’s cheaper and about 30% more space.

No question about it; all these factors have made it a fantastic sellers’ market at the moment.

However, in spite of all this, the market has been remarkably disciplined in its own way. Even with escalating prices, proper pricing remains critical to selling success. The moment a property falls outside of what buyers perceive to be reasonable price parameters, it receives no attention. Few showings. No offers.

So well-educated buyers can still find value properties.

Lastly, the most important reason prices are rising: living in New York City today has never been better.

Too Much Fun…!

Sure, we make compromises on space, and many other things, but no matter the residential pricing, the city hasn’t been this vibrant in decades. NYC’s restaurant scene and night-life are not only innovative and diverse, but are also packed night after night. There are more trees, benches, and recreational activities than ever before. While NYC was once considered a city most suitable for young adults, many families and empty-nesters now prefer the city to the more quiet suburbs. Perhaps the most appealing factor however is that the city is safe. Whenever a customer asks me which neighborhoods are safest, I honestly answer they’re all safe. There’s not a neighborhood on the island that I’m not comfortable walking through today. And that includes north of Central Park! That is a stark contrast to twenty years ago when you were well advised to stay only on well-lit avenues at night.

 

Looking Ahead: Bubble?

Whenever prices start rocketing upwards in NYC, the talk of the next “bubble” is inevitable. But, keep in mind that NYC real estate behaved very differently than the rest of the nation these past several years. At the time of the crisis in 2008, buyers were screaming that the market was down 40% in Manhattan, when we now know retrospectively, our market actually saw only a 20% decrease in overall sales prices. And at the high-end, property values came back in 2-3 years. Similarly, one of the worst downfalls we’ve seen in NYC pricing happened as a result of the 2001 terrorist attacks. The market plummeted even more severely, and then rebounded in 3 months. The current New York City is undoubtedly an efficient market.

 

While the market for sellers is stellar, my advice to buyers is simple: buy exceptional properties as a solid investment at fair market pricing. Or one can explore the fringe of high-growth neighborhoods, which is something I’ll cover in my next piece.

 

 *Matrix Blog, “Bonus for NYC Housing: Wall Street Comp Up 15.1%, Most Cash Paid Out Since ’08 Crash. By Johnathan Miller.

Reset Password

Start an account to create alerts and save your searches and more...

Get notified when new listings match your saved searches.
Save listings and get updated of any changes in price, status and new open houses.
Hide listings that aren't for you so you don't have to see them over and over again.
Get recommendations and stay up-to-date with your dashboard.

Start an account to create alerts and save your searches and more...

Get notified when new listings match your saved searches.
Save listings and get updated of any changes in price, status and new open houses.
Hide listings that aren't for you so you don't have to see them over and over again.
Get recommendations and stay up-to-date with your dashboard.

Sign in instantly with Facebook or Google!

Or sign up the old fashioned way